Prize: 4000 renown points, Mutton of Eternal Hope
Toby from Bloodstone is looking for someone, who will help him put this lawless city in order. Firstly, you must recover the first artifact required for the Purification ritual - the Mutton of Eternal Hope. Follow the trail into a house. You'll find the artifact in a cabinet located in the corner of a room on the first floor. Once you acquire it, go to Toby and give it to him. The Wine of Forgiveness can be found on the first floor of a nearby house, in a wardrobe. The Pie of Kindness - in a house near the shipyard, in a cabinet on the first floor.
The next step is bringing Toby a prostitute. You will find them in the lower part of town, on the coast. Use the "Follow" gesture on one of them, and get back to the house, which you will have to leave in a moment. Talk to some of the town folks, and you will discover who Toby really is. You will also learn, that he has cheated you. Start knocking to the door, until Toby opens. When this happens, throw him out of town (scare him), or kill.