Chain Reaction - Deductions Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter Walkthrough

Final deduction

This is the correct deduction

Mr. Butcher is a murderer

Required assumptions:

• Anarchist ideology;
• Robbed bank;
• Just an anarchist;
• Insufficient knowledge;
• Rasco gang;
• Criminal in the past;
• Fowler's new life;
• Mr. Fowler's work;
• Evil plan;
• Butcher's trap;
• Butcher's problem;
• Butcher's love;
• Underground worker;

In this option you assume that Mr. Butcher is responsible for the bank robbery and murder of his colleagues. You must choose whether to send him to prison or acquit him so that he can help his sick daughter.

Incorrect deductions

Mr. Garrett is a murderer

Required assumptions:

• Anarchist ideology;
• Robbed bank;
• Anarchists and bandits;
• Sufficient knowledge;
• Rasco gang;
• Criminal in the past;
• Fowler's new life;
• Not a specialist;
• Evil plan;
• Butcher's trap;
• Butcher's problem;
• Butcher's love;
• Underground worker;

This theory assumes that mister Garrett is the murderer who robbed the bank and then killed his colleagues. You can condemn him and send to the jail or you can acquit him.

Mr. Fowler is a murderer

Required assumptions:

• Anarchist ideology;
• Robbed bank;
• Just an anarchist;
• Insufficient knowledge;
• Rasco gang;
• Criminal in the past;
• Always a criminal;
• Mr. Fowler's work;
• Evil plan;
• Complex trap;
• Butcher's problem;
• Hopelessness;
• Underground worker;

In this deduction you assume that mister Fowler is responsible for everything. You can send him to jail for robbing the bank and killing the associates or you can justify him with the fact that it was supposed to be his final robbery.