On this page we have provided a walkthrough for achieving the Stink Eye trophy in Assassin's Creed: Odyssey. This achievement is awarded for recovering the Eye of the Cyclops from a goat in Kephallonia. Obtaining this trophy may be problematic because finding the goat won't be easy. All steps are described in detail below.
You can't get this trophy right from the start of the game. You need to complete some initial main quests in Kephallonia, namely unlock The Big Break main quest.
As you complete The Big Break quest, the main character will have a confrontation with Cyclops. Even before this happens, your character will place Eye of the Cyclops in a casual goat during a funny cut-scene.
Finding a goat with the Eye of the Cyclops can be dealt once you have defeated Cyclops and his people. The goat appears in random places in southern Kephallonia. You can increase your chances of finding it by visiting Shepherd's Hill from the picture above. It is adjacent to the village where you fought with the Cyclops - the location of this place is shown in the pictures attached. On this hill you should come across a lot of goats and you can start to kill them and check each of them.
Note - Don't worry if you have left Kephallonia in the meantime. You can return to the starting game location and you will still be able to find a goat with the Eye of Cyclops.
Use your bow and kill more goats. One goat should drop Obsidian Eye Fragment and Obsidian Eye. You will get an achievement.
Note - If you haven't found a goat with the Eye of the Cyclops on the hill we've indicated, you can move away from this location and return to it or explore other areas in southern Kephallonia (e.g. cliffs at the southern end of the island).
Important Note: The obsidian eye is a very valuable gem that you can sell to any blacksmith. It will be for sale together with other useless Trade Goods. For the jewel you will receive 2750 gold from the blacksmith!