Look around the Doncaster Train Station | Riddle On The Rails SH: Crimes and Punishments Guide

Enter the Waiting Hall at the Doncaster Station. Notice a Cigar stub lying on the floor near one of the benches in the center of the hall. Pick it up and sniff it.

Recognizing the kind of the cigar

Rotate it 180 degrees so that the smoke would be on the left side and the mint leaves on the right side of it. Tilt it a bit to match the sombrero with its missing part. Move the leaves to the right so that the lines would fill up the empty space in the sombrero. Drag the smoke down to align all the parts of the hat. You can see the complete hat in the picture below.

Cigar puzzle solution.

Activate Sherlock's talent and approach the ashtray next to the bench. Take the Piece of burnt paper and read the text. Examine the Cigar stub on the left (bigger than the others) and the rest of the Ashtray.

Head to the ticket office on the left, namely to a corridor leading into that room, near the exit to the platform. Examine the Horse racing magazines and Horse racing tickets on the table. Look at them from both sides using the close-up mode.

Leave the building using the door leading to the platform. Watson will notice a Flooded area behind the tracks and a new Evidence will appear in the Casebook. Head right, go past the second entrance to the Waiting Hall and open the next door, leading to the left luggage room. You will see Station master's bag hanging on the wall (on your right) - examine it. Take out A letter to lawyer and read it. Do the same with A letter to wife (2 pages).

Go to the platform and talk to Doncaster Station Master, who is sitting on some luggage.

Duff (Doncaster Station Master) portrait:

• Melancholy (face);
• No watch (right - from player's perspective - upper tail of the uniform);
• Missing button;
• Ring mark (right hand).

Select topics: Flooded area, The passengers and Gambling man. In the QTE, select: Horse racing tickets. Lastly, ask about the Mexican.

Deduction

Connect "Doncaster telegram" with "Doncaster Master received money". You will obtain two Conclusions, from which you will have to choose only one: "Passed Doncaster" and "Missed Doncaster".

When assuming that Robinson is a victim, Chileans were left, the train Missed Chesterfield and Doncaster and that the train was Inside mines, you can end the investigation now (the final conclusion may not be right).

If you assume the following Conclusions: Accident, Robinson's motive, Missed Chesterfield, Missed Doncaster and Inside mines, you can end the investigation now (the final conclusion may not be right).